The Endo Experience - Not What You Expected   Predictable, Successful & Efficient
  Search This Site
Home
For Patients
Referring Doctors
For Professionals
Library
News & Events
Recommended Links
ROOTS
Contact Us
For Professionals
The EndoFiles Fax

<< Back to 2001 Newsletter List


The EndoFiles Fax
February 2001: Volume 2 Issue II

A Periodic Review of Current Clinically Related Endodontic Topics
Tips and hints for the practicing Dentist

With editorial comment provided by:
Robert M. Kaufmann DMD MS (Endo)

Instant Online referrals or Call 783–2971



Antibiotics are not chicken soup

We are all familiar with the expression "Chicken soup…may not help but wouldn’t hurt". We should all be alarmed with the tendency for clinicians to prescribe antibiotics, like chicken soup, without understanding their proper usage. It is understandable that dentists wish to provide relief for their symptomatic emergency patients with the least interruption of their practice day. However, wholesale use of antibiotic prescriptions as an effortless method of "getting the patient out of the office" or "dealing with the symptomatic telephone call" must be condemned.

Understanding pulp pathology precludes the use of antibiotic therapy in vital cases. It is ironic that clinicians who prescribe antibiotics for thermally sensitive "sick pulps", do not recognize that part of the pathology involves compromise of circulation to this organ. Antibiotic therapy is of NO value in the case of pulpitis with a vital pulp. Antibiotics rely on the attainment of an adequate concentration of the medication via the circulation. When pulpal circulation is compromised by inflammation, there is no way for this medication to reach the affected area i.e./ the most coronal or radicular pulp. The most critical management decisions facing the clinician dealing with pulpitis, are whether or not periapical symptoms are present and how to deal with a diseased or dying pulp.

(1) The Thermally Sensitive Tooth with NO Periapical Symptoms – Vital Tooth
The problem is the coronal pulp. Treatment is pulpotomy (or pulpectomy if there is sufficient time). This will relieve the thermal symptoms and allow the patient to be rescheduled for completion of endodontic treatment when time allows. Antibiotics are contraindicated.

(2) The Periapically Involved Tooth – May be Partially Vital or Non-vital
Teeth with periapical involvement will have signs that include slight percussive sensitivity, periapical palpation sensitivity and/or swelling and sometimes visible radiographic periapical pathology. Relief will be most predictably obtained by pulpectomy. Canals should be broached, irrigated and cleaned to approximately size #15 or #20 instrument (if possible) with electronic confirmation of working length. In this way, the minimal remaining pulp remnants have little possibility of increasing the periapical inflammation. Antibiotics are not required as long as you have good instrument length control and do not push canal contents into the periapex . The occlusion is relieved and the patient is placed on anti-inflammatory medication. Routine prescription of antibiotics "just in case", is not supported by the literature.

(3) Post Treatment Exacerbation - (Blow Up)

In rare cases, you may need to place the patient on antibiotics if they develop post pulpectomy blow up. This usually occurs 48 hours after treatment and is due to pushing debris out of the apex. It is more often associated with necrotic or retreatment cases. Pathology is due to inoculation of the periapical area with pulp content and bacteria, inadvertently introduced into this area by a file. When placing instruments in canals, working lengths must be accurate. Use an electronic apex locator (EAL) to prevent being long with files. (See Apex Location Techniques in the next months Endo Fax or the opinions section of www.endoexperience.com for hints on working with an EAL) Confirm working lengths with images (x-ray film or digital radiography).

If the case blows up, there will be PDL inflammation. The tooth will extrude. Pain and periapical palpation sensitivity and swelling will occur. Relief of the occlusion is important for comfort. The first 48 hours post-treatment are the most critical. Good communication with patients prevents cases from getting out of control. Antibiotics should be given immediately in those cases where post operative swelling is reported. It is important to start the medication early and to ensure that the patient does NOT apply heat to the area externally. THERE IS NO SCIENTIFIC BASIS FOR GIVING ANTIBIOTICS AS A "PROPHYLAXIS" IN THE CASE OF THE SINGLE APPOINTMENT TREATMENT OF AN ASYMPTOMATIC NECROTIC TOOTH.

Clinicians considering Antibiotic therapy should read : Baumgartner JC, and Falkner WA. Bacteria in the apical five mm of infected canals JOE 1991;17:380. This article categorizes various antibiotics used in treatment as well as indications for their use.

The continued irrational use of antibiotics as "do something" treatment, contributes to the proliferation of antibiotic resistance. The consequences will probably not be apparent to clinicians in their middle or late career years. The problem will no doubt escalate in the future, as bacteria become more resistant and we are left with fewer effective drugs. Those of us prescribing in a haphazard manner may well be responsible for a situation where our children and grandchildren have fewer and fewer alternatives for treating serious bacterial infection in other, more critical areas of the body.


Current Recommended Antibiotics for Pulpally Related Dental Problems:
Drug Dosage Indication
Penicillin Vk 300 mg qid Drug of choice
Amoxicillin 250 or 500 mg tid Wider Spectrum
Clavulin (Amox and Clavulanate) 250 or 500 mg tid For Pen Resistant bacteria
Erythromycin 250 mg qid For Pen allergic patients
Clindamycin 150-300mg qid Patients not responding to above

Since many of my referred symptomatic cases have already been on medication (usually Pen Vk), I have begun to move toward Clindamycin as the drug I prescribe most. However, it is more expensive than Pen Vk and should not be used if patient is showing signs of steady improvement. Although there was some initial reluctance to use Clindamycin for dental problems because of its published association with ulcerative colitis, my experience with this medication has been very positive. Aside from occasional GI upset and minor diarrhea, serious complications have not occurred when used in short duration. It is very effective in cellulits cases and post treatment blow ups.

Responsible use of antibiotic therapy is part of good dental practice. The use of antibiotics as scattergun treatment for problems of unknown etiology is poor clinical practice. Antibiotics are not "chicken soup" and clinicians should not use them in that manner. Clinicians who are unwilling to take the time to properly diagnose and treat a problem or who are not able to make a definitive diagnosis should opt for referral.

The Endo Files is provided free of charge. If you know a Dentist who would like to receive a copy,
e-mail, call (204)783 2971 or fax at (204)786 7467 and request that they be put on the mail or fax list.